Turn your valuables into cash with confidence at Mustache Gold & Silver. Whether you’re looking to sell gold, silver, diamonds, or rare coins — or hoping to buy quality precious metals — our Lakewood team offers fair pricing, honest evaluations, and a friendly, stress-free experience. Walk in anytime and get fast, reliable service from trusted local buyers.
Every item is tested and weighed in front of you so you always know exactly what you’re getting.
We explain the value of your items clearly. You decide if you want to sell, with zero obligation.
We follow current market rates and provide straightforward pricing without hidden fees or commissions.
At Mustache Gold & Silver, turning your valuables into cash is quick, simple, and stress-free. Whether you have old jewelry, coins, bullion, or unwanted precious metals, we offer top, fair market prices and a smooth, no-pressure selling experience.
Bring your gold or silver to our Lakewood location for an on-the-spot evaluation and instant payment. Honest offers. Fast service. Trusted experts.
EXCELLENT Based on 51 reviews Posted on Google Christina CarrierTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Andrew is a great guy, super easy to work with. Highly recommendPosted on Google Jan LaBrieTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. First, I visited the precious-metals dealer in Belmar, who gave me a ballpark offer due to stones still being in some of the jewelry, which obviously increases the weight. He appreciated my telling him that I would be talking to at least one other dealer. After about 15 minutes, he made an offer that he believed would be accepted by his boss. I made a mental note of the amount, thanked him, and from there, I went straight to Mustache Gold and Silver with the same items. Andrew spent about an hour with me, explaining things and chatting while he worked - he's very personable! He asked if he could remove all of the stones. I agreed to that, and because of that and the fact that Andrew is his own boss, he was able to give me a firm offer. I accepted it and walked out with a check that was 150% of the offer from the other dealer! I highly recommend Andrew!!Posted on Google Laeslie StokesTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Great place. Very reasonable on both ends. Andrew is a very cool guy. Won't go anywhere else!!! Ever.Posted on Google Lindsey Lee MarieTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Andrew was honest and very helpful. I highly recommendPosted on Google Yjon CuypersTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Great shop, reliable and friendly service. 5 stars! Certainly worth a visit.Posted on Google Timothy ColbyTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Very friendly and makes a fair deal.Posted on Google Heather FosterTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Andrew was more than fair with good gold scrap pricing. Will be bringing all of my scrap here from now on. Thanks so much!Posted on Google Robert DarrahTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Nice quality, syllables and quick easy way to sell your own. Thanks.Posted on Google Jonathan SweetingTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Really great experience with Andrew- will definitely come again!
Stop by with your jewelry, coins, or bullion. Our team greets you and answers any questions before we begin.
We test and weigh everything in clear view and explain what each item is worth based on current market prices.
If you decide to sell, we complete the transaction and pay you immediately. No waiting and no hassle.
Selling your valuables should feel straightforward, not stressful. That’s why we keep every step open and easy to follow. From the moment you walk in, our team walks you through the evaluation so you understand exactly what you have and what it’s worth.
Whether it’s a single piece of jewelry or a full collection of coins and bullion, we give each item the attention it deserves. Our offers are based on current market prices, and you’re always free to decide what you want to sell. You stay in control the entire time.